|
Post by Waddling Mummies GM on May 27, 2009 14:36:51 GMT -5
Pos - Player - Team - $ - yrs left/contract length QB Donovan McNabb, Eagles $4 QB Trent Edwards, Bills $1
RB Reggie Bush, Saints $6 RB Marshawn Lynch, Bills, $4 RB Darren Sproles, Charges, $3 RB Ray Rice, Ravens $2
WR Andre Johnson, Texans $7 WR Jeremy Maclin, Eagles $3 WR Reggie Wayne, Colts $4 WR Torry Holt, Jaguars $1 WR Ted Ginn Jr, Dolphins $1
TE Dallas Clark, Colts $2 TE Brent Celek, Eagles $1
K
DL Gaines Adams, Buccaneers $5 DL Lamarr Woodley, Steelers, $5 DL Julius Peppers, Panthers, $5 DL Aaron Shobel, Bills, $2
LB Ray Maulaluga, Bengals, $3 LB Trent Cole eagles $5 LB David Harris, Jets $4 LB Brian Cushing, Texans, $1 LB Julian Peterson, Lions $1 LB Brian Urlacher, Bears $1
CB DeAngelo Hall, Redskins $2 CB
S Brandon Meriweather, Patriots $4 S Adrian Wilson, Cardinals $3 S Ed Reed, Ravens $3
IR IR IR IR IR
Roster: 27/35 Salary: $82/$100
Practice Squad
Pos - Player - Team - $ - yrs left/yrs for contract PS Cornelius Ingram TE Eagles, $1 PS Mike Thomas WR Jaguars $1 PS PS PS
Roster: 2/5 Salary: $2/$10
Suspended List
|
|
|
Post by Waddling Mummies GM on May 28, 2009 15:03:22 GMT -5
You have a stellar D! I love your WR and TE! QB is not great but it is servacible and McNabb got his weapons he wanted so we will see if he is happy. The one thing i dont like is your RB. i dont like Bush at all. Can Lynch stay out of trouble? Will Sproles get enough carries? How much time will Rice get to see with 2 other rb in the mix? Im just have concerns with all your rb. But Andre and Wayne rock!!
|
|
|
Post by Washington Imperials GM on May 28, 2009 22:22:49 GMT -5
Players Drafted 29
Weak Position RB it's not the best place to be weak Bush can be a PPR beast if healthy but that is the problem he hasnt been healthy the last two years and Lynch will miss games this year Rice will become the starter if not this year but next. You need anopther RB for the 2009 season it will help cover up the risk this group brings. there is enough on roster to temporarily cover injuries and suspension but another RB ius nessessary. 2010 and beyond I think this group could surprise.
I will neglect that you have 1 CB because the position is volitile. if it is a warm body it is capable of being a CB2 or 3.
Strong position. First is DL at one of the thinnest positions you covered yuorself well. I shudder for later this season if Trent Cole plays enough DE to gain it's eligibility.
WR is strong as well. Johnson, Wayne, and Holt are a nice 1,2,3 punch with Maclin in the wings to become a playmaker. Ginn is a wild card. He will make or break this staff he is the depth that is crucial for you to make a playoff run.
Ed Reed as your third S?!!! I did not realize how strong that is until I reviewed you roster.
Starters vs Depth you have the starters through your lineup and I like the depth of your LBs I like the fact you have older vets for this year and two top rookie LBs for the future it is a nice combination.
Best Pick Marshawn Lynch you capitalized on the value freefall of Lynch as a RB2 I really like him.
Worst Pick: Call it plitting hairs but Trent Cole his LB only eligibility make him an OK LB but not a great one and not worth the spot selected. ESPN screwed you there if he regains DE eligibility iCole loses this moniker.
Riskiest Pick: Reggie Bush .... injury history
Specail Note I really like what you did with your practice squad so far. Ingram is thwe future when Celek is done and Mike Thomas should be comming into his own when Holt retires.
I really want to grade this a B but with the criteria I have given I find no reason to give it one. One might say taking Bush in the early second round but I can find justifications for it
|
|
|
Post by Phantoms GM on May 30, 2009 2:15:38 GMT -5
I gave you an A, I disagree with Imperials I think Bush was a good pick, despite his injuries. I also love your receivers and McNabb will be a good QB for the next 3-4 years. You have stars at every level of your defense except CB, but they are a dime a dozen.
|
|
|
Post by Washington Imperials GM on May 30, 2009 6:16:28 GMT -5
I gave you an A, I disagree with Imperials I think Bush was a good pick, despite his injuries. I also love your receivers and McNabb will be a good QB for the next 3-4 years. You have stars at every level of your defense except CB, but they are a dime a dozen. ehhhehhheh....(read indedcision. I don't think Bush is a bad pick and I think Early round two is allright for him and it is a reasonable spot to take him It's more of a personal thing and he does bring risk to the table in can he stay healthy. He;s alright to me. and I tried not to hold my personal feelings against people if they drafted a player about where they were supposed to be. what I did fail to state in the l;ast post because I though it was evident in the voting at that time. Is I in fact did grade this team an A. I wouldnt find a reason to lower this teams greade.
|
|
|
Post by hojounk on Jun 3, 2009 10:35:03 GMT -5
Gotta go with C + cause at RB and QB.... RB to start off.. Lynch will miss 4 games and besides him u have RB's who will split time.. U have guys that can u give u tons of points in one week but may also give u little points the next.... Mcnabb is a top 15 QB, edwards is around a top 20 ... u have 2 top 10 WR maybe even 2 top 5.... your D looks pretty good especially at the DL spot... but I am not greatly high on the LB's u have... they are good but not great
|
|
|
Post by Tulsa Roughnecks GM on Jun 8, 2009 1:36:25 GMT -5
Strengths: Great overall draft except at CB. Love your depth at all other positions. Killer DL. This is a solid roster across the board that will deliver consistent points every week.
Weaknesses: CB and no real LB1. Ted Ginn stinks. Peterson and Urlacher may be has-beens, but at least you got them at the right price.
Guy you stole from me: Again, several candidates here. I'll go with RB Ray Rice. He could crack your starting lineup before too long, and that's no slam on Bush or Lynch.
|
|
|
Post by Washington Imperials GM on Jun 24, 2009 17:35:43 GMT -5
Trent Cole is now a DL because ESPN came to thier senses. This Dl very well could hve become the best in the league
|
|